7ASR3d254
BILLY JOE LARSON, a
minor, by BILL LARSON,
his guardian ad litem,
Plaintiff,
v.
RAY McMOORE and SESE
McMOORE, Defendants.
________________________________
PEARLITA CANDY FUAVAI,
Intervenor/Defendant.
High
Court of American Samoa
Land
and Titles Division
LT
No. 12-01
July
17, 2003
[1] “Next
friend” is a term that was developed at common law, usually for a person
designated to prosecute a civil action on a plaintiff minor’s behalf, while a
“guardian ad litem” referred to a person appointed to present a defendant
minor’s defense. However, in current
practice and in American Samoa, the term “guardian ad litem” is used whether
the minor is a party plaintiff or defendant.
[2] Where
constructed rock wall encroached on property and diverted traffic upon
property, owner of rock wall was liable for trespass.
[3] One is
subject to liability to another for trespass if he enters land in the
possession of the other, or causes a thing or a third person to do so.
[4]
An irrevocable license, sometimes referred to as an easement by estoppel,
arises where an owner or occupier of land permits another to use that land
under circumstances in which it was reasonable to foresee that the user would
substantially change position believing that the permission would not be
revoked, and the user did substantially change position in reasonable reliance
on that belief.
[5] Whether or
not to issue a mandatory injunction for removal of an encroachment, when the
encroachment was not intentionally erected on another’s property, is within the
Court’s discretion.
[6] When an encroachment is unintentional, the Court must balance the
hardship to the defendants against the benefit to the plaintiff; if the former is
great and the latter is slight, the court will ordinarily leave the plaintiff
to his remedy at law.
[7] Where rock wall prevented plaintiffs from fully exercising their
rights to the enjoyment of their lands, diverting traffic upon one plot and
rendering nugatory rights-of-way, an injunction directing removal of the wall
was appropriate.
[8] Actual
physical interference with the use and enjoyment of another’s land constitutes
the most common type of nuisance and is properly subject to the issuance of a
permanent injunction.
[9] A
continuing trespass that can be abated is properly eliminated by injunctive
relief.
Before
RICHMOND, Associate Justice, and ATIULAGI, Associate Judge.
Counsel: For Plaintiff, Jeffrey Waller and
Marshall Ashley
For Defendants, Tauivi Tuinei and Arthur
Ripley, Jr.
For Intervenor/Defendant, Afoa L. Su`esu`e
Lutu
OPINION
AND ORDER
This action
concerns removal of a rock wall that allegedly blocks a right of way and
diverts entrants across land owned by plaintiff Billy Joe Larson (“Billy Joe”),
a minor, to reach other land. Defendants
Ray McMoore (“Ray”) and Sese McMoore (“Sese”) (together “the McMoores”) admit
that they constructed the rock wall, but deny that the right of way exists and
claim that the rock wall is entirely on their land. Even though the lands involved are
individually-owned lands and the issue did not require the Secretary of Samoan
Affairs’ involvement under A.S.C.A. § 43.0302, upon the request of Bill Larson
(“Larson”), Billy Joe’s adoptive father, the Secretary informally mediated the
issue, but without success. Larson then
filed this action as Billy Joe’s “next friend,” without judicial appointment.
[1] “Next friend” is a
term that was developed at common law, usually for a person designated to prosecute
a civil action on a plaintiff minor’s behalf, while a “guardian ad litem”
referred to a person appointed to present a defendant minor’s defense. See 1 California Civil
Procedure Before Trial § 19.1 (3d ed. 1990). In current practice, however, the term
“guardian ad litem” is more commonly understood and used whether the minor is a
party plaintiff or defendant, id., and is the usual designation in this
jurisdiction. Both terms are still
viable, provided the representative in this capacity is judicially
appointed. T.C.R.C.P. 17(c). We therefore directed Billy Joe’s counsel to
have Larson appointed by the Court as Billy Joe’s formal representative in this
action, preferably as Billy Joe’s guardian ad litem. This was done in due course.
Discussion
A. Factual Background
Four subdivided
lots are involved.[1] The lots are within a larger parcel of land, in
Ili`ili, American Samoa, originally owned by Ione Fe`a (“Fe`a”) as his
individually-owned land. The portion of
the larger parcel at issue is cone-shaped with the apex at the north end. For purposes of this discussion, we designate
the lots by number. Lot 1 encompasses
the apex and is owned by Intervenor/Defendant Pearlita Candy Fuavai
(“Fuavai”). Fuavai was not originally
made a party to this action. After the
trial, the Court added Fuavai as a necessary party for full and proper
adjudication of the issues, as she is owner of land accessed by crossing Billy
Joe’s land with the rock wall in place.
Lot 2 is the second lot southwest down the left side. Sese owns Lot 2. Lot 3 is the first lot southeast down the
right side of the cone. Billy Joe is the
beneficial owner of Lot 3. Lot 4 lies
between Lots 2 and 3 south of Lot 1.
Ray, Sese, or the McMoores hold the title to Lot 4, informally in trust
for the McMoore’s grandchildren.
During the
planning for the subdivision of the larger parcel, in 1989 and 1990, Fe`a
instructed the surveyor to provide for rights of way (“ROWs” when plural and
“ROW” when singular) to ingress and egress the lots. Legal descriptions of these ROWs, however,
were not officially recorded with the Territorial Registrar. Nevertheless, the evidence, based on the
registered deeds and subsequent surveys, affirmed the existence of the ROWs,
intended for the benefit and enjoyment of all the adjoining landowners. We designate the relevant ROWs by
letter. ROW A lies between Billy Joe’s
Lot 3 and the McMoores’ in-trust Lot 4, abuts with Sese’s Lot 2 and ROW C at
its north end, and is 15’ wide. Ray was
instrumental in developing and still assists in maintaining ROW A, even though
the McMoores can access Lot 2 and Lot 5 without using ROW A. ROW B lies between Lot 1 and Billy Joe’s Lot
3, would provide access from the end of ROW A to Lot 1, and is also 15’
wide. ROW C lies between Lot 1 and
Sese’s Lot 2, extends north from the end of ROW A, and is 7.5’ wide.[2] The McMoores profess to no knowledge of the
existence of ROW B and ROW C.
In 1990, Fe`a
conveyed approximately seven acres of the larger parcel, in two separate
transactions of three acres and four acres, to Fuga Teleso (“Fuga”). Lot 3 lies within the three-acre transaction. In 1990, Fuga conveyed Lot 3 to Eletise M.
Wolman (“Eletise”). In 1994, Eletise
conveyed Lot 3 to Senovefa Pritt (“Senovefa”).
Eletise and Senvoefa are native Samoans entitled to own land in American
Samoa; their husbands, Lewis Wolman (“Lewis”) and Ray Pritt, are nonnatives and
are not authorized to acquire title to individually-owned land in the
territory. A.S.C.A. § 37.0204(b). In 2000, Senovefa conveyed Lot 3 to Billy
Joe, with Margie Faaita holding title as trustee until Billy Joe reaches age
18.
Also in 1990,
Fe`a conveyed Lot 1 to Fuavai. This
transaction was recorded with the Territorial Registrar. The evidence initially suggested that Lot 1
was later subdivided into two unrecorded lots, now separately occupied. After Fuavai was joined as a necessary party
and further evidence was introduced, it became clear that Fuavai did not
subdivide Lot 1, the present separate occupants of portions of Lot 1 are
trespassers, and Fuavai timely objected to their occupancy and plans, if
necessary, to take formal action to evict these occupants.
In 1991, Fe`a
conveyed Lot 2 to Sese. It is unclear
under the evidence whether Ray, Sese, or the McMoores hold the title to Lot 4,
or the year when this title was acquired (though clearly some time after the
1991 conveyance to Sese but before the trial of this action). Though also unclear, it appears that Fuga was
the grantor of the Lot 4 transaction, as he owned the major portion of the
larger parcel after his two acquisitions from Fe`a in 1990.[3]
At the time Fe`a
conveyed Lot 2 to Sese, or shortly after, a meeting on site was held. The attendees included Lewis representing his
wife Eletise, and Ray for himself and his wife Sese, Fuga, and Sina Fe`a
(“Sina”) representing her father Fe`a.
Sina handled most of Fe`a’s land transactions. Neither Fuavai nor her representative was
present. The McMoores had recently had
Lot 2 resurveyed. They understood that
the northeast boundary of Lot 2 immediately abutted the southwest boundary of
Lot 1, thus encompassing ROW C, and that the southeast boundary of Lot 1
immediately abutted the northwest boundary of Billy Joe’s Lot 3, thus
encompassing ROW B. The attendees, Lewis
included, discussed access to Lot 1 from the north end of ROW A, and agreed to
permit use of a strip along the northwest boundary of Lot 3, then owned by
Eletise, for such access.
In 1994, the
McMoores constructed the rock wall Billy Joe wants removed. The rock wall begins on the southeast
boundary of Lot 2 and extends from there across the south end of ROW C to the
southwest corner of ROW B. Because of
the rock wall’s positioning, persons are prevented from entering ROW B from ROW
A and must use the stretch of Lot 3 permitted by Lewis to access Lot 1.
B. Legal Analysis
Based on the
evidence, there is no legal basis that allows the rock wall to remain standing.
[2-4] The rock wall is not
situated entirely on Sese’s Lot 2.
Instead, it physically encroaches on the 7.5’ ROW C and cuts off access
to ROW B while diverting traffic across Billy Joe’s Lot 3. By both encroaching on ROW C and causing
others to stray onto Lot 3, the McMoores are committing a trespass by their
rock wall. See Letuli v. Le`i,
22 A.S.R.2d 77, 82 (Lands and Titles Div. 1992); Restatement (Second) of Torts § 158 (1965) (“One is subject
to liability to another for trespass [if he] enters land in the possession of
the other, or causes a thing or a third person to do so”).[4]
[5-6] Whether or not to
issue a mandatory injunction for removal of an encroachment, when the encroachment
was not intentionally erected on another’s property, is within our
discretion. See Whitlock v. Hilander
Foods, Inc., 720 N.E.2d 302, 307 (Ill. App. Ct. 1999) (no balancing if
encroachment was deliberate); Ridgway v. TTnT Dev. Corp., 26 S.W.3d 428,
433 (Mo. Ct. App. 2000) (same); Annotation, Mandatory injunction to compel
removal of encroachments by adjoining landowner, 28 A.L.R.2d 679 § 8 (1953) (hereinafter “Annotation”). We do not find that the McMoores
intentionally erected the rock wall outside Sese’s Lot 2 on ROW C; instead,
they were simply mistaken about the property line. Thus, we must “balance the hardship to the
defendant[s] against the benefit to the plaintiff; if the former is great and
the latter is slight, the court will ordinarily leave the plaintiff to his
remedy at law.” Whitlock, 720 N.E.2d at 307; Annotation at § 6.
In this case, we find that the balance tips in favor of removal. Though the cost of the removal of the wall is
not expressly in evidence, it will be relatively nominal, even done by
inexpensive self-help, and the hardship to Fuavai and Billy Joe wins out. As of now, Fuavai is not able to fully
exercise her rights to the enjoyment of her Lot 1. The rock wall renders nugatory ROW B and ROW
C, which were intended as access to Lot 1.
Instead, the wall forces Fuavai to enter Lot 1 by crossing Lot 3. Moreover, the 7.5’ encroachment on ROW C
cannot be considered slight. But see Whitlock, 720 N.E.2d at 307-08; Generalow v. Steinberger, 517 N.Y.S.2d 22, 24 (1987).
Additionally, Billy Joe is injured because parties entering Lot 1 will
continue to use his Lot 3. Unless the
rock wall comes down, the trespass on Lot 3 will be permanent, also depriving
Billy Jo of the lawful enjoyment of his land.
See Thompson v.
Toluao, 24
A.S.R.2d 127, 132-33 (Land and Titles Div. 1993) (“Actual
physical interference with the use and enjoyment of another’s land constitutes
the most common type of nuisance and is properly subject to the issuance of a
permanent injunction”); Letuli, 22 A.S.R.2d at 86 (“continuing trespass
that can be abated is properly eliminated by injunctive relief”); A.S.C.A. §
43.1302.
Order
The McMoores
shall remove the rock wall from ROW C.
Removal shall be made within a reasonable time, not to exceed 90
days.
It is so
ordered.
**********
[1] We take judicial notice of the consolidated
actions LT Nos. 14-93, 20-93, 10-95, 20-96, and 1-98 to complete certain
details of the land transactions set forth below in the factual findings. We also take judicial notice and have
inspected the Territorial Registrar’s records of these transactions.
Additionally, we have appended to this
opinion and order a not-to-scale diagram of the subdivided area, marked Exhibit
A, to provide a picture of the area described below.
[2] It appears that
Fea intended ROW C to be 15’ wide, taking the additional 7.5’ from the Sese’s
Lot 2. However, that extension is not
clearly ascertained from the evidence and is not presently an issue before us.
[3] At the present time, the conveyance of Lot 4,
whether by Fe`a or Fuga, has been neither received nor recorded in the
Territorial Registrar’ Office.
[4] There was some
evidence to support the McMoore’s contention that Lewis, representing Eletise
when she owned Lot 3, acquiesced to the McMoores’ construction of the rock wall
knowing that it would cause traffic to divert onto Lot 3. And, there was some evidence that Lewis’
permission was intended to be permanent. Thus, the McMoores’ argument that they
acquired an irrevocable license is not frivolous. An irrevocable license, sometimes referred to
as an easement by estoppel, arises where:
[an] owner or occupier [of land]
permit[s] another to use that land under circumstances in which it was
reasonable to foresee that the user would substantially change position
believing that the permission would not be revoked, and the user did
substantially change position in reasonable reliance on that belief.
Vaoga v. Wong, 7 A.S.R.3d 246,
248 (Land and Titles Div. 2003) (quoting
Restatement (Third) of Property: Servitudes § 2.10(1) (2000))
(alterations in original).
But, besides the
need for caution in extending equitable land rights in American Samoa, we need
not reach this issue. Firstly, because any permission was merely oral, no
explicit easement was granted. Thus, it
is not clear that Billy Joe is bound by Lewis’ actions. Secondly, Lewis did not have the sole
authority to grant the McMoores permission to build a wall on property outside
their Lot 2—in this case ROW C.
Therefore, at the very least, there is no justification for that
encroachment.
